In his book meat, a benign extravagance, author and onetime editor of the ecologist, simon fairlie, painstakingly deconstructs these figures. A benign extravagance written by british activist and former livestock farmer, simon fairlie, meat was published last year in the uk, and has recently made it over the pond to us, thanks to chelsea green publishing. B it is the first study to discuss both the vegan and nonvegetarian. Simon fairlies book lays out the reasons why we must. An abattoir for dodgy arguments 1 this will not be an easy column to write. A benign extravagance characterised in paragraph 3. Not a simple answer, but one that takes all views on meat eating into account. He did an abrupt uturn after reading simon fairlies book, meat a benign extravagance. Wills book is one of the key practical resources you should readas you reach for full sustainable soil fertility in your garden or farm. His fair treatment of veganism has more to do with intellectual honesty than admiration. A benign extravagance is the sanest book i have read on the subject of how the human race is going to feed itself in the years ahead. The issue of eating meat is a touchy one, especially here in vancouver a trendsetting city that has.
Fairlies book is exhaustively researched, and one of the most intelligent and thorough arguments for sensible. He runs a microdairy at monkton wyld court community in dorset, and the scythe shop, offering austrian scythes and beginners scything courses. Jun 05, 2019 the bias in this document against peasant farming is discussed in s fairlie 2010, meat. I have been particularly fascinated, for example, by the work of a remarkable man called allan savory, in zimbabwe and other semiarid areas, who has argued for years against the prevailing expert view that it is the simple numbers of cattle that drive overgrazing and cause fertile land to become desert. A benign extravagance, argues that a more subtle approach to the environmental impact of eating meat is needed, taking full account of how livestock can be constructively integrated into agricultural systems.
The meatproducing system fairlie advocates differs sharply from the one now practised in the rich world. If you want to save the world, veganism isnt the answer. Sep 15, 2010 meat a benign extravagance is an exploration of the difficult environmental and ethical issues that surround the human consumption of animal flesh. Some livestockrelated beliefs that now enjoy favored nation status do not survive his witty yet exacting scholarship. It lays out in detail the reasons why we must decrease the amount of meat we eat, both for the planet and for ourselves, and explores how different forms of agriculture shape our. A benign extravagance, simon fairlie lays out an extremely detailed, multilayered argument for how small default amounts of meat production can be part of a sustainable agricultural system. A benign extravagance, published by chelsea green 2010, right around the same time i wrote what some might consider a rather controversial blog on the subject of meat on urbandiner. The kuroiler is a hybrid breed of chicken developed by the keggfarms group in gurgaon, haryana. A benign extravagance may only bruise veganism, but its a bruise that will not soon heal.
The bias in this document against peasant farming is discussed in s fairlie 2010, meat. Fairlie asserts that smallscale, local livestock rearing can be an environmentally neutral, or even beneficial, aspect of sustainable food. He then subjects their case to the first treatment ive read that is both objective and forensic. Simon fairlie, a former farmer, now editor of the land magazine, delves into the issue in his book meat. Simon fairlie takes a detailed look at the environmental side of the issue. Pdf emotions, truths and meanings regarding cattle. Kuroilers are derived from crossing either coloured broiler males with rhode island red females, or, white leghorn males crossed with female rhode island reds characteristics. A it initially favours a vegan lifestyle but ultimately rejects it. Aug 25, 2018 intensively farmed meat and dairy are a blight, but so are fields of soya and maize. Will bonsalls essential guide to radical, selfreliant.
A benign extravagance by simon fairlie chelsea green publishing, 2010 in the debate between vegans and omnivores there is. Click download or read online button to get the meat we eat book book now. Meat a benign extravagance is an exploration of the difficult environmental. I no longer believe that the only ethical response is to stop eating meat.
English, ifoam, in the financial times food security briefing. Oct 21, 2014 i would highly recommend the book meat. Meat a benign extravagance is an exploration of the difficult environmental and ethical issues that surround the human consumption of animal flesh. As monbiot notes, fairlie himself credits vegans for initiating. Lab meat the idea of in vitro meat ivm from hereon, or cultured meat, is to grow meat from animal cells with the help of tissue engineering andor 3d printing technology. A benign extravagance, folks, this aint normal a word on gmos.
Meat is indeed benign in the best of scenarios, yet often extravagant, too. A benign extravagance is an abattoir for misleading claims and dodgy figures, on both sides of the argument. A benign extravagance, fairlie, simon, logsdon, gene. Simon fairlie on why eating meat is good for the planet time. A benign extravagance by simon fairlie chelsea green publishing, 2010 in the debate between vegans and omnivores there is disagreement not just about which dietary approach is. Garnering huge praise in the uk, this is a book that answers the question. A benign extravagance, and the rural planning handbook.
Kuroilers are derived from crossing either coloured broiler males with rhode island red females, or, white leghorn males crossed with female rhode island reds. Gene logsdon, author of holy shit and the contrary farmer simon fairlie provides us with an unusual and extremely important gift in his new book, meat. A benign extravagance journal of food law and policy, vol. A benign extravagance by simon fairlie the weston a. Apr 05, 2018 in his book meat, a benign extravagance, author and onetime editor of the ecologist, simon fairlie, painstakingly deconstructs these figures. Simon fairlies meat a benign extravagance is the sanest book i have read on the subject of how the human race is going to feed itself in the years ahead gene logsdon. Calls for us all to switch entirely to plantbased foods ignore one of the most. From pimentals total, we can calculate that such a cow uses over 12 million litres of water. He brings to this book several decades of practical experience of farming, a critical quantitative approach and whole systems thinking. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. A benign extravagance is a groundbreaking exploration of the difficult environmental, ethical and health issues surrounding the human consumption of animals. A benign extravagance, simon fairlie pays handsome tribute to vegans for opening up the debate. Fairlie is a powerhouse thinker, a fire hose of ideas. A benign extravagance is an exploration of the difficult environmental, ethical and health issues surrounding the human consumption of animal flesh.
I think that perhaps the title of the book says it in a nutshell. Pdf envisioned technologies can make and be motivated by ethical spaces. Even convention raised beef spend the vast majority of their lives on pasture, utilizing land unsuited for agriculture in many cases they are replacing previously displaced ruminants like bison thus enhancing biodiversity and carbon sequestration. First, many people actually have no idea what genetic modification is and will comment saying, genetic modification has been going on for thousands of years. A benign extravagance should help align some more fanciful proposals for the future of farming along more practical furrows. The small farm model with animals has a history reaching into antiquity.
Vegans are wrong, meat is merely a benign extravagance peter smith. He then subjects their case to the first treatment ive read that is both objective and. Pdf the vegan book of permaculture download full pdf book. It lays out in detail the reasons why we must decrease the amount of meat we eat, both for the planet and for ourselves, and explores how different forms of agriculture shape our landscape. John jeavons, author, executive director of ecology action, and developer of sustainable biointensive minifarming. The worlds meat consumption is rapidly rising, leading to devastating environmental impacts as well as having long term health implications for societies everywhere. Fairlie is one of the editors of the excellent magazine, the land. Kuroilers, a dualpurpose breed producing meat and eggs, can live on a diet of kitchen and agricultural. The meat we eat book download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi. Kuroilers, a dualpurpose breed producing meat and eggs, can live on a diet of kitchen and.
This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. It lays out in detail the reasons why we must decrease the amount of meat we eat, both for the planet and for ourselves, and explores how different forms of agriculture shape our landscape and culture. The increasing popularity and prominence of veganism gives simon fairlies 2010 book, meat a benign extravagance, a topical relevance. Click download or read online button to should we eat meat book pdf for free now. A benign extravagance is a groundbreaking exploration of the difficult. He points out that a typical beef steer, reared for 500 days, produces 125 kilos of meat at slaughter. A benign extravagance is not a scorching antiveganism polemic. As monbiot notes, fairlie himself credits vegans for initiating and widening the debate and persuading. Not a simple answer, but one that takes all views on meat eating into.
In looking at the environmental consequences of what we eat and how we produce it, author simon fairlie tallies up plenty of points in veganisms favor. Under gwp a drop in methane emissions of 10 percent over 30 years is equivalent to zero tonnes co2 emissions. Fairlies book is exhaustively researched, and one of the most intelligent and thorough arguments for sensible, sustainable meat production and. Image not found or type unknown meat a benign extravagance is most popular ebook.
He then subjects their case to the first treatment ive. The inspiration for monbiots change of mind is a new book meat. In the debate between vegans and omnivores there is disagreement not just about which dietary approach is nutritionally better, but which is better for the environment. Meat a benign extravagance at complete pdf library. Aug 02, 2018 additional sources to read on this topic. The issue of eating meat is a touchy one, especially here in vancouver a trendsetting city that has more than its share of. It lays out in detail the reasons why we must decrease the amount of meat we eat, both for the planet and for ourselves, and explores how. A benign extravagance, simon fairlie, a british farmer and former editor of the ecologist magazine, tears apart the theory that being carnivorous is bad for the planet and says that eating moderate amounts of meat could be greener than going vegan. Humans are naturally omnivorous, predisposed to eating both plants and animals. Avaliable format in pdf, epub, mobi, kindle, ebook and audiobook. Should we eat meat download should we eat meat ebook pdf or read online books in pdf, epub, and mobi format.
1206 251 547 1121 1458 774 437 744 251 1100 126 789 1166 949 1048 1494 1023 871 629 972 1083 439 474 849 1124 1488 771 1126 615 885 35 656 285 283 1254 233 715 1053 397